Carly Smithson appears on American Idol Extra after being eliminated from “American Idol” and talks about her journey in the show

Smithson however seem fine despite being vote out and commented audiences “never got the chance to see how happy and bubbly she really is”

Carly is the seventh of twelve finalist of American Idol to be eliminated on Wednesday morning after receiving the lowest number of phone-in votes

What probably audiences will remember about Carly is her previous album released on MCA Records prior to Idol participation and that led to plenty of fans upset, as the American Idol show is all about finding new talent

But Carly Smithson is not the only one with a prior history of professional career, as former duo Idol participants Kristy Lee Cook and Michael Johns band also had a major-label contract

Still contesting in the show, David Archuleta also had won $100,000 on “Star Search”

Fans have every reason to be upset as the show is turning into more of a rehash of singers has-been platform, vying for their second chance in the music industry